Removing a Patron: When Does Force Become Excessive? What Alberta Security Guards Should Know

Removing a Patron: When Does Force Become Excessive? What Alberta Security Guards Should Know

Last Updated on November 16, 2026

Security guards working in Alberta’s nightclubs, entertainment venues, hospitals, and retail establishments regularly encounter situations where individuals refuse to leave private property.

While many of these encounters can be resolved through communication, others can escalate into verbal confrontations or physical resistance. Alcohol, drugs, mental illness, and heightened emotions can all influence how an individual responds when directed to leave.

For security professionals, these situations require quick thinking, sound judgment, and a clear understanding of their legal responsibilities.

For those pursuing a career in security, understanding legal authority and appropriate intervention is an essential part of professional preparation. At Alberta Guard Training, we recognize the importance of building a strong foundation in these responsibilities.

In some circumstances, physically removing someone from a property may be necessary. However, having the authority to remove an individual does not mean that any level of force is acceptable.

So, when does reasonable force become excessive?

An August 2026 incident at a Winnipeg nightclub raises important questions about security guards’ legal authorities, the importance of communication, and the consequences of physical interventions that may cross legal boundaries.

Although the incident occurred in Manitoba, the lessons are equally relevant to security professionals working throughout Alberta.

The Incident: Three Security Guards Charged

At approximately 1 a.m. on August 3, 2026, Winnipeg police responded to a disturbance at a nightclub in the 400 block of Main Street.

According to police, a 28-year-old patron had been involved in an altercation with security personnel and required hospital treatment for his injuries.

The patron was later identified as Teddy Allen, a professional basketball player with the Winnipeg Sea Bears.

According to news reports, video footage taken inside the nightclub shows Allen being forcefully removed by at least three security guards.

On August 12, three security guards were arrested and charged with assault causing bodily harm.

It is important to emphasize that criminal charges are allegations, not findings of guilt. The available reporting also does not provide a complete account of the events leading up to, during, or following the confrontation.

Nevertheless, the incident provides an opportunity to examine how security guards should approach similar situations and why understanding the limits of legal authority is essential.

Understanding a Security Guard’s Authority in Alberta

Security guards in Alberta are often responsible for enforcing property rules on behalf of business owners, property managers, and other authorized individuals.

For example, a nightclub manager may decide that an intoxicated patron must leave because of aggressive or disruptive behaviour.

Security personnel may then be directed to communicate that decision and ensure the individual leaves the premises.

When the patron cooperates, the situation can often be resolved without further intervention.

However, when someone refuses to leave, security guards must understand which legal authorities apply and what actions are permitted.

Alberta’s Trespass to Premises Act

Alberta’s Trespass to Premises Act establishes rules governing unauthorized access to certain properties.

Under the legislation, property owners and their authorized representatives can provide notice that an individual is not permitted to enter or remain on the premises.

Notice may be provided verbally, in writing, or through properly displayed signage, depending on the circumstances.

Section 5 of the Act also permits a peace officer, property owner, or authorized representative of the owner to apprehend a trespasser without a warrant in qualifying circumstances.

When someone other than a peace officer apprehends a trespasser under this provision, they must deliver that individual to a peace officer as soon as practicable.

For Alberta security guards, this distinction is important.

A security guard acting as an authorized representative of a property owner may have certain enforcement powers, but those powers are not unlimited.

The existence of an arrest authority does not automatically justify the use of physical force in every situation.

Security professionals must understand the applicable legislation, their employer’s policies, and the circumstances that make intervention legally appropriate.

Criminal Code Section 35: Defence of Property

In addition to provincial trespassing legislation, security guards must understand the protections and limitations established by the Criminal Code of Canada.

Section 35 of the Criminal Code addresses the defence of property.

Generally speaking, the section allows individuals in peaceable possession of property, or those acting under their authority, to take reasonable action to protect that property.

This may apply when someone enters a property without legal authority, interferes with property, or refuses to leave after being directed to do so.

However, the law requires that the actions taken be reasonable in the circumstances.

Having the authority to remove someone does not automatically make every method of removal lawful.

In the Winnipeg nightclub incident, the manner in which the guards removed Teddy Allen has been called into question.

The situation demonstrates why security professionals must distinguish between having the authority to act and ensuring that their actions remain legally justified.

Reasonable Force: Understanding the Limits

When a confrontation becomes physical, security guards must continually assess whether their response is appropriate to the situation.

The National Use of Force Framework provides a conceptual approach to assessing situations and selecting appropriate responses.

Although the framework was developed for policing, its principles can also support decision-making in private security.

It is important to recognize that the framework is not legislation and does not independently authorize the use of force.

Instead, it helps professionals consider factors such as:

  • The individual’s behaviour and level of resistance.
  • The surrounding environment and potential hazards.
  • The seriousness and immediacy of any threat.
  • The availability of assistance or alternative responses.
  • Changes in the individual’s behaviour throughout the incident.

Security situations are rarely static.

For example, a patron who initially refuses to leave may become cooperative after receiving clear instructions. Alternatively, an individual who was cooperating may suddenly become aggressive.

As circumstances change, the response must change accordingly.

The key principle is that any force used must remain reasonable and legally justified.

Once the threat has ended or the objective has been achieved, continued force may no longer be justified.

Communication: The First Step Toward De-escalation

Many security incidents begin with a simple verbal interaction.

A security guard approaches someone, explains that they must leave the premises, and requests their cooperation.

However, being asked to leave can trigger feelings of embarrassment, frustration, anger, or fear.

These emotions may cause the individual to argue, refuse instructions, or become confrontational.

The way a security guard communicates can have a significant influence on how the situation develops.

Maintaining a calm but directive tone, explaining expectations clearly, and allowing the individual an opportunity to comply can help prevent unnecessary escalation.

One effective strategy is the Refusal Approach.

The Refusal Approach

1. Ask Again

Clearly repeat the request.

“I would like you to leave the club.”

2. Reason

Explain why the individual is being asked to leave.

“When you pushed our server, you violated our violence and harassment policy.”

3. Benefits

Explain the advantages of cooperating.

“If you leave on your own, there won’t be a scene, and you’re welcome to come back another night.”

4. Options

Explain the lawful options available if the individual refuses.

“If you refuse to leave, we may need to escort you out or request police assistance.”

5. Confirmation

Confirm that the individual understands the request and provide an opportunity to comply.

6. Action

Follow through with the appropriate response based on the individual’s behaviour and the available legal authorities.

If the individual agrees to leave, allow them to do so voluntarily.

If they refuse, reassess the situation and determine the safest lawful response.

This structured approach helps security personnel maintain control of the interaction while giving the individual opportunities to cooperate.

While communication cannot prevent every physical confrontation, it remains one of the most important tools available to security professionals.

Team Intervention and Individual Accountability

The Winnipeg nightclub incident involved multiple security guards participating in the removal of Teddy Allen.

In potentially violent situations, a coordinated team response can improve safety for security personnel, patrons, and bystanders.

However, effective teamwork requires more than simply having several guards involved.

Each member of the team must understand their role, communicate effectively, and work toward the same objective.

Without coordination, a physical intervention can quickly become chaotic.

Training helps security professionals understand how to respond as a team while maintaining appropriate control over their individual actions.

It is equally important to recognize that each security guard remains responsible for their own conduct, even when acting as part of a team.

The fact that multiple guards are involved does not remove individual accountability.

In the Winnipeg incident, three security guards were charged in connection with the confrontation. The legal process will determine the outcome of those allegations.

For Alberta security professionals, the incident reinforces the importance of coordinated responses, clearly defined responsibilities, and ongoing training.

Key Lessons for Alberta Security Guards

The Winnipeg incident highlights several lessons that apply to security professionals working throughout Alberta.

1. Understand Your Legal Authority

Security guards must know the difference between enforcing property rules, removing individuals, and making arrests.

Alberta’s trespassing legislation and the Criminal Code establish different legal authorities that must be understood and applied appropriately.

2. Prioritize Communication

Physical intervention should be considered only when necessary and legally justified.

Clear instructions, patience, and effective de-escalation strategies can often prevent confrontations from becoming physical.

3. Work Together Effectively

When multiple guards are involved, clearly defined roles and coordinated communication help maintain safety.

Every team member must understand their responsibilities and remain accountable for their actions.

4. Continuously Assess the Situation

An individual’s behaviour can change rapidly.

Security guards must continually evaluate whether their response remains appropriate and adjust their actions as circumstances evolve.

5. Recognize the Consequences of Excessive Force

Using force that is not legally justified can have serious consequences, including:

  • Criminal charges.
  • Civil liability.
  • Loss of employment.
  • Licensing consequences.
  • Physical injuries.
  • Damage to professional reputation.

Understanding these risks is an important part of working responsibly in Alberta’s security industry.

Why Proper Security Guard Training Matters in Alberta

Security guards working in Alberta encounter a wide variety of situations that require professionalism, sound judgment, and an understanding of legal responsibilities.

From managing disruptive patrons at entertainment venues to enforcing access restrictions at commercial properties, security personnel must be prepared to respond appropriately.

Quality security guard training provides a foundation in important areas such as legal authorities, communication, conflict management, and professional conduct.

However, learning should not stop once a security guard receives their licence.

Ongoing professional development helps guards strengthen their decision-making skills and better prepare for challenging situations.

The Winnipeg nightclub incident demonstrates how quickly a physical confrontation can lead to serious legal consequences.

It also reinforces an important principle: effective security is not about using the greatest amount of force possible. It is about understanding when intervention is necessary and ensuring that every action remains reasonable, professional, and lawful.

At Alberta Guard Training, we understand the importance of preparing security professionals for the responsibilities that come with working in the industry.

Whether you’re just beginning your career or looking to strengthen your professional knowledge, developing a solid understanding of legal authorities, communication, and conflict management is an important step toward becoming a confident, capable security guard.

Ready to take the next step in your security career?

Visit AlbertaGuardTraining.ca to explore our security guard training opportunities and get started.

References

Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police. (2000). A national use of force framework.
https://www.cacp.ca/_Library/resources/National_Use_of_Force_Framework.pdf

Criminal Code, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-46, ss. 26, 34, 35.
https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-46/

Government of Alberta. Trespass to Premises Act, R.S.A. 2000, c. T-7.
https://kings-printer.alberta.ca/

Government of Manitoba. (1987). The Trespass Act, C.C.S.M. c. T156.
https://web2.gov.mb.ca/laws/statutes/ccsm/t156.php

Patterson, K. (2026, August 13). 3 security guards facing assault charges after Winnipeg Sea Bears’ Teddy Allen injured. CityNews Winnipeg.
https://winnipeg.citynews.ca/2026/08/13/teddy-allen-injury-security-guards-assault/

Winnipeg Police Service. (2026, August 13). Assault investigation at licensed premise results in charges: C26-191112. City of Winnipeg.
https://www.winnipeg.ca/police/community/news-releases/2026-08-13-assault-investigation-licensed-premise-results-charges-c26-191112

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>