Date: April 23, 2025
Location: Prospera Place, Kelowna, BC
Event: Bush Concert
What was supposed to be a night of music and entertainment quickly spiraled into a violent and chaotic scene. Multiple altercations between security personnel and intoxicated fans were captured by witnesses and widely reported by news outlets such as Global News and Oak Bay News.
Some attendees accused guards of using excessive force—alleging actions like slamming a woman face-first onto the ground. Others defended the guards, pointing out they were being scratched, punched, and even choked by aggressive concertgoers. Either way, the event revealed a common but dangerous challenge in the security world: how do you maintain order without crossing the line into excessive force?
Why This Matters for Security Professionals
Large events like concerts are high-risk environments. Crowds, alcohol, poor lighting, noise, and limited staffing create a perfect storm of tension. In those moments, decisions must be made quickly—but they must also be defensible, legal, and proportionate.
This post breaks down:
- What “reasonable force” really means in Canada.
- How to assess and respond to threats.
- A 5-step decision-making framework for security guards.
- Realistic scenarios to guide better practice.
- How to protect yourself from legal and reputational harm.
What Is Excessive Force?
Excessive force is any use of physical control that exceeds what is reasonably necessary to handle a situation. Under the Criminal Code of Canada, several sections provide use-of-force authority to security personnel:
- Section 25: Allows guards to use reasonable force in the execution of lawful duties.
- Section 34: Covers self-defence.
- Section 35: Covers defence of property.
- Section 26: States that any unreasonable use of force can result in criminal liability.
These laws share one common thread: force must be reasonable, necessary, and proportionate.
A 5-Step Framework for Reasonable Use of Force
When situations escalate, use this structured process to assess and act appropriately:
1. Threat Assessment
Ask:
- Is the person passively resisting, actively resisting, or assaultive?
- Are they a threat to themselves, others, or property?
- Are there signs of intoxication, mental health issues, or drug use?
Example:
A fan is violently shoving others near the stage and refusing to comply. This is assaultive behavior and may require physical intervention.
2. Attempt De-Escalation
Always try verbal options first, unless immediate risk requires physical control.
- Use calm but firm language.
- Offer clear choices (e.g., “You can stay if you calm down, or you’ll be escorted out”).
- Allow the person space to comply while maintaining observation.
Example:
A shouting fan can be asked to step aside and given a chance to cool down before being removed.
3. Use Minimal Force Necessary
Choose the least intrusive option that achieves control.
- Escort holds: For passive resistance.
- Soft control techniques: For moderate resistance.
- Hard control or takedowns: Only for high-risk or violent resistance.
Example:
If a fan refuses to leave but is not fighting, an escort hold is appropriate—not a takedown.
4. Reassess Continuously
Force decisions must evolve with the subject’s behaviour.
- If aggression increases, guards may escalate appropriately.
- If the subject de-escalates, so should the force level.
Example:
If a subject calms down during escort, reduce force to maintain professionalism and legality.
5. Document Thoroughly
Good reporting protects you.
- What was the threat?
- What alternatives were attempted?
- What kind of force was used, and why?
- Was it proportionate to the resistance?
- How did the subject behave before, during, and after?
Poor or missing documentation can lead to liability—even if the force used was justified.
Realistic Event Scenarios: What Security Should Do
✅ Scenario A: Intoxicated, Disruptive Fan
Situation:
A drunk fan is pushing others, yelling, and ignoring verbal commands.
Good Approach:
- Warn verbally: “Please stop pushing or you’ll be removed.”
- If ignored, use escort holds with two guards.
- If resistance escalates, apply transport holds or takedown (if necessary).
Bad Approach:
- Skip de-escalation.
- Use excessive force (e.g., slamming into barriers).
- Shout or insult the fan.
✅ Scenario B: Physically Assaultive Fan
Situation:
A fan punches a guard and charges the stage.
Good Approach:
- Use distraction strikes and takedown to regain control.
- Apply handcuffs if trained and authorized.
- Reduce force once threat is neutralized.
Bad Approach:
- Engage in a fistfight out of retaliation.
- Verbally threaten or insult the subject.
- Continue using high force after control is achieved.
✅ Scenario C: Verbal Insults Only
Situation:
A fan yells profanities and insults but makes no threats.
Good Approach:
- Stay calm and professional.
- Use verbal techniques to de-escalate or ignore.
- Focus on your job, not your ego.
Bad Approach:
- Physically intervene without cause.
- Respond with insults or threats.
- Let anger override judgment.
Why Public Perception Matters More Than Ever
Every guard today works in front of an audience—with cameras.
- Expect to be recorded.
- You can’t control what gets posted.
- A single viral video can damage your company’s brand and lead to criminal or civil litigation.
Even if force is legally justified, bad optics can destroy your reputation.
Pro Tip:
Always act like you’re being filmed—because you probably are.
Practical Tips for Security at Public Events
- ✅ Know and apply the National Use of Force Framework.
- ✅ Focus on de-escalation first.
- ✅ Stay emotionally in control.
- ✅ Operate as a team whenever possible.
- ✅ Use clear, loud, simple verbal commands.
- ✅ Preserve dignity—treat people with respect.
- ✅ Write detailed, professional reports.
Final Thoughts
There is no perfect formula for how much force to use—it depends on the situation. But there is a right process for making decisions. When security guards are trained to assess threats, control their emotions, act proportionately, and document clearly, they protect themselves and the public.
The Kelowna incident is a reminder: training and professionalism aren’t optional. They’re the foundation of good judgment.
Looking to Improve Your Use of Force Skills?
Explore certified, professional training options at SecurityGuardCourse.ca and ensure your team is prepared to handle high-pressure situations lawfully and effectively.
References:
- Femia, V. (2025, April 25). Fans allege security at Bush concert in Kelowna were using ‘excessive force’. Global News.
- Cunningham, J. (2025, April 25). GSL Group ‘aware of recent incidents’ after alleged altercations at Kelowna concert. Oak Bay News.